Why Listen?

by Diane Hopkins on May 1, 2010



“Pick up your shoes!”

“Clear the table!”

“You’ve left your coat on the couch.”

“Don’t leave a wet towel on your bedroom floor!”

Sound familiar? I sometimes feel like I am a repeating public announcement: “Keep your hands and feet inside the vehicle until it comes to a complete stop” . . . “No smoking in the terminal”.

I don’t want to be a nag, and I know kids can easily go “parent deaf” if much of our communication is just remind-remind-remind. I was thinking hard about this when it hit me—why should they listen?! Is there any benefit involved? Is there any good reason to tune in to a parent’s constant reminders? Or is it just mom going through the drill of repeating, reminding and nagging?

Having had this brilliant thought, it occurred to me to make it worth my daughter’s while to pick up the towel off her bedroom floor—or better yet, to motivate her not to ever throw it there in the first place. This was my biggest gripe and my constant nag, so—without any fanfare—I posted a note on the bathroom mirror: “$1 charge for a towel on the floor”.

Guess how many times she paid $1? Actually just once! Unfortunately, I had trained her to ignore me, to know that I would repeat it over a few more times before expecting action. So, she didn’t really believe that I meant what I posted. I saw the towel on her floor and playfully demanded payment with out-stretched hand: “Aha! I caught you! One dollar, please!”

Oh my, I was for real! Now there was a reason to listen. Now she was on guard! It became worth her while to regulate herself.

This didn’t make me feel very good. Oh, yes, I was thrilled to be able to stop reminding her, but I felt rather bad that I had allowed myself to become a negative background noise. The cure was just too easy. That was 3 months ago and it is still working. There have been no towels on her floor ever, even though the note is long gone. Why? Well, it finally became beneficial for her to change her behavior. I wish I could have realized that earlier, and saved my breath!

Next time you open your mouth to issue a command, to nag or remind, ask yourself, “why should they listen?” Once there is a reason that benefits them, they’ll hear quite well even if it is whispered just once, or posted without a word.

To your parenting success!

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }


     I'd sure love to hear your comment!

K'Lyn Thomas May 17, 2010 at 8:54 pm

This was perfect. I have 3 young children and although I would like to praise all the time, there are things that need to be taken care of and I do not like asking 10 times to have something happen. I knew I had 'help' create that response, but more than anything wanted another perspective idea. Thank you so much for helping my brain step outside my box. I always feel empowered and more confident as I read the things you share. Thanks so much!

Charrise Larez May 4, 2010 at 9:02 pm

Hi Diane, I was wondering if throwing personal belongings away after 2 warnings is too punitive? I feel like I am at my witt's end sometimes and I get into a whirlwind of cleaning-aka-throwing stuff that is on the floor away and never to see it again…Please help. thank you
Charrise In Hayward, Ca

Heather May 3, 2010 at 6:46 pm

You have no idea how much I needed to hear this today! Why just this morning I fell over numerous pairs of shoes in front of the door (where, I have told my kids a million times…"one pair of shoes only in front of the door and put them there NEATLY, so that no one trips over them !!!!"). Yet again, I threatened them today that if I find them like that again they will be grounded for the rest of the day. Sounds a bit harsh, I know. The sad part is that I would put money the fact that they were thinking….she will not…she'll forget she ever said that. Thanks for this post….I believe will go get some sticky notes. Hey, I may have just found a rather lucrative part-time job! :)

Mary Siever May 3, 2010 at 5:34 pm

Thank you Diane. I so needed to hear this.

Robin J. Steinweg May 2, 2010 at 2:12 pm

EUREKA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Zounds, this may work. I thank thee, Diane. I hope to be back with an update at some point.
:) Robin

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }


     I'd sure love to hear your comment!

K'Lyn Thomas May 17, 2010 at 8:54 pm

This was perfect. I have 3 young children and although I would like to praise all the time, there are things that need to be taken care of and I do not like asking 10 times to have something happen. I knew I had 'help' create that response, but more than anything wanted another perspective idea. Thank you so much for helping my brain step outside my box. I always feel empowered and more confident as I read the things you share. Thanks so much!

Charrise Larez May 4, 2010 at 9:02 pm

Hi Diane, I was wondering if throwing personal belongings away after 2 warnings is too punitive? I feel like I am at my witt's end sometimes and I get into a whirlwind of cleaning-aka-throwing stuff that is on the floor away and never to see it again…Please help. thank you
Charrise In Hayward, Ca

Heather May 3, 2010 at 6:46 pm

You have no idea how much I needed to hear this today! Why just this morning I fell over numerous pairs of shoes in front of the door (where, I have told my kids a million times…"one pair of shoes only in front of the door and put them there NEATLY, so that no one trips over them !!!!"). Yet again, I threatened them today that if I find them like that again they will be grounded for the rest of the day. Sounds a bit harsh, I know. The sad part is that I would put money the fact that they were thinking….she will not…she'll forget she ever said that. Thanks for this post….I believe will go get some sticky notes. Hey, I may have just found a rather lucrative part-time job! :)

Mary Siever May 3, 2010 at 5:34 pm

Thank you Diane. I so needed to hear this.

Robin J. Steinweg May 2, 2010 at 2:12 pm

EUREKA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Zounds, this may work. I thank thee, Diane. I hope to be back with an update at some point.
:) Robin

Leave a Comment